Menu
*Please note, only our Gluten Free pizzas are available in the 12″ size. Not all ingredients are gluten free so please be sure to confirm with our staff before placing your order. We have Dairy free options available as well.
The City: Our Classic Pizzas
The Pyro Pie
NEW!! This pizza is literally exploding with flavor! Classic marinara, mozzarella cheese, Pepperoni, Sweet Goathorn Peppers (mild), seasoned & roasted tomato wedges, topped with freshly diced basil leaves.
Gluten Free (12") $19.99
14" $20.91
18" $26.99
24" $37.99
Giant slice $6.39
The New Yorker
- Our classic cheese pizza
- Gluten Free (12") = $16.99
- 14” = $13.75
- 18” = $16.99
- 24” = $23.99
- Giant Slice = $3.79
The Godfather Deluxe (LOADED W/ RONI)
- Loaded with Pepperoni (3X)
- Gluten Free (12") = $19.99
- 14” = $19.12
- 18” = $23.74
- 24” = $34.49 & Giant Slice = $5.74
The Bronx Deluxe
- Pepperoni, Italian sausage, Minced garlic
- Gluten Free (12") = $19.99
- 14” = $19.12
- 18” = $23.74
- 24” = $34.49
- Giant Slice = $5.74
The Brooklyn Deluxe
- Pepperoni, minced garlic. fresh chopped basil
- 14” = $19.12
- 18” = $23.74
- 24” = $34.49
- Giant Slice = $5.74 | Gluten Free (12") $19.99
The Harlem
- Meatballs, jalapeños, cream cheese drizzle
- 14” = $19.12
- 18” = $23.86
- 24” = $34.49
- Giant Slice = $5.74 | Gluten Free (12") = $19.99
The Yankee
- Breaded chicken, black olives, mushrooms
- Gluten Free (12") = $19.99
- 14” = $19.12
- 18” = $23.74
- 24” = $34.49
- Giant Slice = $5.74
The Beach Bum
- Canadian bacon, pineapple, roasted red peppers
- 14” = $19.12
- 18” = $23.74
- 24” = $34.49
- Giant Slice = $5.74
- Gluten Free (12") = $19.99
The Mobster
- (Meat Lovers) Pepperoni, Italian sausage, meatballs, bacon
- 14” = $20.91
- 18” = $25.99
- 24” = $37.99
- Giant Slice = $6.39
- Gluten Free (12") = $21.99
The Grand Central
- Pepperoni, Italian sausage, mushrooms, black olives, onions
- 14” = $22.70
- 18” = $28.24
- 24” = $41.49
- Giant Slice = $7.04
- Gluten Free (12") = $21.99
Madison Square Garden: Our Vegetarian section
All of your veggies freshly delivered, and hand cut in shop by our staff to guarantee the best possible toppings for your pizza!
The Central Park
- (Veggie Supreme): Spinach, black olives, red onions, green peppers, mushrooms
- 14” = $22.70
- 18” = $28.24
- 24” = $41.49
- Giant Slice = $7.04
- Gluten Free (12") = $21.99
The Park Ave
- Fresh tomatoes, red onion, artichoke hearts, finished with pesto over the top
- 14” = $20.91
- 18” = $25.99
- 24” = $37.99
- Giant Slice = $6.39
- Gluten Free (12") = $21.99
The Soho
- Garlic oil base, sun-dried tomatoes, spinach, feta
- 14” = $20.91
- 18” = $25.99
- 24” = $37.99
- Giant Slice = $6.39
- Gluten Free (12") = $19.99
The Manhattan
- Red onions, fresh tomatoes, spinach, minced garlic
- 14” = $20.91
- 18” = $25.99
- 24” = $37.99
- Giant Slice = $6.39
- Gluten Free (12") = $19.99
The Queens
- Artichoke hearts, spinach, sun-dried tomatoes
- 14” = $19.12
- 18” = $23.74
- 24” = $34.99
- Giant Slice = $5.74
- Gluten Free (12") = $19.99
The Athens
- Black olives, red onions, spinach, feta
- 14” = $20.91
- 18” = $25.99
- 24” = $37.99
- Giant Slice = $6.39
- Gluten Free (12") = $19.99
The Staten Island
- Fire roasted tomato base, fresh basil leaves, red onions
- 14” = $19.12
- 18” = $23.74
- 24” = $34.49
- Giant Slice = $5.74
- Gluten Free (12") = $19.99
The Times Square
- Zesty garlic broccoli, fire roasted tomatoes, mushrooms, red onions
- 14” = $20.91
- 18” = $25.99
- 24” = $37.99
- Giant Slice = $6.39
- Gluten Free (12") = $19.99
5th Avenue: Our deluxe section
The Grand Central
- (Supreme): Pepperoni, Italian sausage, mushrooms, black olives, red onions
- 14” = $22.70
- 18” = 28.24
- 24” = $41.49
- Giant Slice = $7.04
- Gluten Free (12") = $21.99
The Spicy Mushroom
- Spicy marinara, mushrooms, pepperoni, red onions, tomatoes, minced garlic
- 14” = $24.49
- 18” = $30.49
- 24” = $44.99
- Giant Slice = $7.69
- Gluten Free (12") = $21.99
The Long Islander
- Garlic Alfredo base, sun-dried tomatoes, red onion, breaded chicken
- 14” 20.91
- 18” = $25.99
- 24” = $37.99
- Giant Slice = $6.39
- Gluten Free (12") = $19.99
The Ultimate B.L.T.
- Bacon, grilled chicken, lettuce, fresh tomatoes, ranch dressing drizzled over the top
- 14” = $22.70
- 18” = $28.44
- 24” = $41.49
- Giant Slice = $7.04
- Gluten Free (12") = $21.99
The Gyro Pizza
- Gyro meat, red onions, fresh tomatoes, lettuce, with fresh tatziki sauce drizzled over the top
- 14” = $22.70
- 18” = $28.24
- 24” = $41.49
- Giant Slice = $7.04
- Gluten Free (12") = $21.99
The Bruschetta Pizza
- Homemade pesto base, artichoke hearts and tomatoes in a balsamic blend, parmesan cheese
- 14” = $20.91
- 18” = $25.99
- 24” = $37.99
- Giant Slice = $6.39
- Gluten Free (12") = $19.99
Creamy Bruschetta Pizza
- Cream cheese base, artichoke hearts & tomatoes in a balsamic blend, pesto over the top
- 14” = $22.70
- 18” = $28.24
- 24” = $41.49
- Giant Slice = $7.04
- Gluten Free (12") = $19.99
The All American
- Mozzarella and cheddar cheese, grilled chicken, red onions, jalapeños , tater tots, and drizzled with our house honey beer barbeque sauce
- 14” = $24.49
- 18” = $30.49
- 24” = $44.99
- Giant Slice = $7.69
- Gluten Free (12") = $21.99
The Buffalo Chicken Pizza
- A blended buffalo sauce base, grilled chicken, red onions, and tomatoes. ranch or bleu cheese on the side or drizzled over the top
- 14” = $22.70
- 18” = $28.24
- 24” = $37.99
- Giant Slice = $6.39
- Gluten Free (12") = $21.99
The Sicilian
(Deep dish pizza): Our traditional pizza served on a thick 16” square crust
16" = $21.99
Additional toppings = $1.60 **$1.99
The Meat Breakfast Pizza
Scrambled eggs as the base, Italian sausage, bacon, onion, green peppers, cheddar & mozzarella cheese, tater tots & cinnamon sugar crust
14” = $22.99
The Veggie Breakfast Pizza
Scrambled eggs as the base, tomatoes, mushrooms, onion, green peppers, cheddar & mozzarella cheese, tater tots & a cinnamon sugar crust
14" = $22.99
Build your own!
Gluten Free = $1.00 | 14″ = $.1.79 | 18″ = $2.25 | 24″ = $3.50 | Giant Slice = $0.65
DAIRY FREE ITEMS AVAILABLE NOW!
Deluxe top notch toppings**
Gluten Free $1.00 | 14″ = $1.79 | 18″ = $2.25 | 24″ = $3.50
CHEESE
- -Extra Mozzarella
- -Ricotta
- -Feta
- -Cream Cheese
- -Cheddar cheese
- -NEW: Dairy Free Mozzarella
SAUCES
- -Classic Marinara
- -Spicy Marinara
- -Pesto
- -Olive Oil and Garlic
- -Garlic Alfredo
- -Cream Cheese
- -Spicy Cream Cheese
- -Cream Cheese & Pesto blend
- -Honey Beer BBQ
- -Creamy buffalo sauce(spicy bleu)
- -Eggs
- -Fire Roasted Tomatoes
- -Franks Red Hot
- -Tradition or X-Hot buffalo sauce
- NEW: Dairy Free Marinara
MEATS
- Bacon
- -Grilled Chicken
- -Breaded Chicken
- -Spicy Chicken
- -Barbeque Chicken
- -Canadian -Bacon
- -Meatballs
- -Pepperoni
- -Italian Sausage
- -Gyro meat
- Anchovies
VEGGIES
- -NEW Sweet Hungarian Goathorn peppers (mild)
- -NEW Seasoned Roasted Tomato Wedges
- -Artichoke Hearts
- -Black Olives
- -Green Olives
- -Green Peppers
- -Fresh Jalapeños
- -Mushrooms
- -Red Onion
- -Roasted Red Peppers
- -Green Chilie
- -Broccoli
- -Zesty Garlic Broccoli
- -Spinach
- -Banana Peppers
VARIOUS
- -Pesto
- -Pineapple
- -Tomatoes
- -Fire Roasted Tomatoes
- -Tater Tots
- -Sun Dried tomatoes
- -Fresh Basil
- -Cream cheese
- -Tzatziki (cucumber sauce)
- -Ranch
- -BBQ sauce
- -Spicy Ranch
- -Spicy Bleu Cheese
- -Sweet n’ Sour Chili Sauce topping/base
- -Franks Red Hot
- -Any of our wing sauces
Side items
Garlic Knots
Casbah's version of garlic bread. Our dough tied into a knot, baked, seasoned with our garlic sauce and topped with melted mozzarella with marinara sauce for dipping
6 $4.99 - 12 $9.99
Supreme Garlic Knots
Choose any 3 toppings to be cooked over your garlic knots
6 $6.50 & 12 $12.99
Mozzarella Sticks
Breaded mozzarella deep fried and served with marinara for dipping
6 $6.99 & 12 $13.99
Wings
Wings: Traditional Hot
Comes with a side of ranch or bleu cheeses
6 wings $7.50 - 12 wings $14.99
Wings: Ragin’ X-Hot
Comes with a side of ranch or bleu cheeses
6 wings $7.99 - 12 wings $14.99
Wings: Death Hot
Comes with a side of ranch or bleu cheeses
6 wings $7.50 - 12 wings $14.99
Wings: Honey Beer Barbeque
Comes with a side of ranch or bleu cheeses
6 wings $7.50 - 12 wings $14.99
Wings: Spicy Garlic
Comes with a side of ranch or bleu cheeses
6 wings $7.50 - 12 wings $14.99
Wings: Spicy Garlic Teriyaki
Comes with a side of ranch or bleu cheeses
6 wings $7.50 - 12 wings $14.99
Wings: Teriyaki
Comes with a side of ranch or bleu cheeses
6 wings $7.50 - 12 wings $14.99
Wings: Zesty Garlic Parmesan
Comes with a side of ranch or bleu cheeses
6 wings $7.50 - 12 wings $14.99
Wings: Spicy Barbeque
Comes with a side of ranch or bleu cheeses
6 wings $7.50 - 12 wings $14.99
Wings: Honey Mustard
Comes with a side of ranch or bleu cheeses
6 wings $7.50 - 12 wings $14.99
Wings: Spicy Honey Mustard
Comes with a side of ranch or bleu cheeses
6 wings $7.50 - 12 wings $14.99
Wings: Sweet N’ Sour Chili Sauce
Comes with a side of ranch or bleu cheeses
6 wings $7.29 - 12 wings $14.50
Salads
House Salad
Fresh tomatoes, red onions, mozzarella cheese on top of crisp romaine lettuce
Side $4.99 – Full $8.99– Party Size $39.99
Greek Salad
Crisp romaine, black olives, red onions, feta, tomatoes, tzatziki dressing.
Side $4.99 – Full $8.99– Party Size $39.99
Caesar Salad
Crisp romaine lettuce sprinkled with parmesan cheese
Side $4.99 – Full $8.99– Party Size $39.99
Pita sandwiches
7" toasted pita bread topped with fresh ingredients prepped daily
Buffalo Chicken Pita Sandwich
7" toasted pita bread topped with breaded chicken tossed in our house buffalo sauce, lettuce, tomatoes, red onion, and your choice of ranch or bleu cheese dressing.
$6.99
Chicken BLT Pita Sandwich
7" toasted pita bread topped with your choice of grilled or breaded chicken, bacon, lettuce, tomatoes, and onion. Finished with ranch or bleu cheese
$6.99 Double meat $1.99
Gyro
7" Toasted pita bread stuffed with gyro meat, tomatoes, onions, lettuce, and homemade tzatziki sauce
$6.99 Double meat $1.99
Chicken Caesar Pita Sandwich
Toasted pita bread sprinkled with parmesan cheese stuffed with a fresh Caesar salad and your choice of grilled or breaded chicken
$6.99 Double meat $1.99
"THE GUS " deluxe gyro
Named after the Greek legend himself, the man that put Casbah gyros on the map, Gus Zahakis.
7" Toasted pita bread loaded with gyro meat, cooked mushrooms and (your choice of) pepper, feta cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, onions, tzatziki sauce, and a lite drizzle of hot sauce
$8.99 Double meat $1.99
Sweet Things
Zeppolis
- Bits of fried dough coated in cinnamon or powdered sugar, and layered with creamy frosting
- Small $3.99 | Large $7.99
3 mini Cannolis
- Stuffed with rich cannoli cream
- $4.99
3 mini Chocolate Cannolis
- Stuffed with rich cannoli cream
- $5.50
Drinks
Sodas
- Coke, Diet Coke, Cherry Coke, Sprite, Barqs Root Beer, Mellow Yellow, Lemonade, Raspberry Ice Tea
- 22oz = $1.45 | 32oz = $1.99
Liter Sodas
- Liter Sodas
- Coke, Diet Coke & Sprite
- $3.25
Draft Beers
Rotating drafts from New Belgium Brewing & Odell Brewing Co.